Methods · Perspective, simulation & context
D9
Viva simulation
Be examined out loud, with follow-up questions that respond to what you actually said, which is a completely different skill from writing, and is assessed without ever being taught.
When to use it
- An oral, viva, OSCE, or interview is coming and you have only practised in writing.
- You can write fluent answers but freeze when follow-ups chase a weakness.
- You need to practise saying “I don’t know” without collapsing.
What to ask AI
Type something like: “Examine me orally on synaptic plasticity as a sceptical undergrad viva examiner. One question at a time. Base each follow-up on the weakest part of my last answer. Include two questions I probably cannot answer.”
Say you will answer out loud and paste a rough transcript.
Ask for feedback on content and delivery at the end, not mid-answer help.
How it helps
Oral examination tests skills writing does not: thinking at speaking speed, handling responsive follow-ups, saying you don’t know well, recovering from a bad answer.
Those skills are assessed often and practised rarely, because they need another person.
AI is a stand-in for volume practice, not a perfect match for a real panel.
How to run it
- Speak out loud; typing removes the skill you are training.
- Name a specific examiner type and level.
- Forbid looking things up mid-answer.
- Require follow-ups aimed at your weakest point.
- Deliberately practise two questions you will not know.
- Get feedback on hedging, filler, and whether you answered the question asked.
Example exchange
Undergrad viva on long-term potentiation. Be a sceptical examiner,one question at a time, don’t lecture.
In one minute: what changes at the synapse in LTP, and how would you measure it?
More AMPA receptors, stronger postsynaptic response… measured with field potentials?
You hedged on measurement. What does a field potential actually show, and what can it not show?
Copyable prompt
Examine me orally on [TOPIC], as [a sceptical examiner at X level / an OSCE
examiner / a PhD viva panel]. Rules: one question at a time; base each follow-up
on the weakest part of my last answer; don't help me; include two questions I
probably can't answer. I'll answer out loud and type a rough transcript. At the
end, give me feedback on both content and delivery, including whether I
answered the question asked or a different one I preferred.
The Tell
You know this method has flipped when you perform well in soft chat conditions and freeze in the real room.
Comfortable typing is not viva practice.
Add time pressure, speech, and at least one human listener before the day.
Principle evidence
Strength of the underlying learning idea, not a claim about AI products.
The underlying learning idea is rated moderate. Viva/oral exam simulation is retrieval + argumentation under questioning (transfer-appropriate processing; oral assessment traditions).
AI delivery evidence
Whether an AI tutor delivers this method well is a separate question.
Principle moderate; AI examiner isomorphism to real viva speculative.